When I left Mimi Smith in my previous blog, she was renting out rooms in her home to university students, struggling with her husband’s gambling and his debts, but aside her money problems Mimi was happy and John had settled down to a life at Mendips with his aunt Mimi, uncle George and all their beloved pets. However, in late 1949 and for the next ten years life changed for Mimi and she found herself challenged once again.
George Ernest Stanley had been a tenant at 9 Newcastle Road and when he died on the 2nd of March 1949 at the Smithdown Hospital 126 Smithdown Road of bronchopneumonia he left his effects solely to daughter Julia Lennon (married) and this being a sum of £464.9s.9d. Julia with her partner Bobby Dykins had resided with George since they had left the flat at 51 Menlove Gardens West in late 1946. On the 5th of March 1947 Julia gave birth to her first child with Bobby and this was Julia Dykins. When George passed away in March 1949 Julia was only a couple of weeks pregnant with their second child who was due Christmas 1949 and although she had been left the inheritance, her and Bobby could not afford to purchase Newcastle Road even though they were given first option to buy.
After persuading the Liverpool Corporation that they were married, Bobby was able to secure a three bedroomed semi-detached council house on the Springwood Estate near Garston, and in the August of 1949, Julia, Bobby and Julia junior moved into 1 Blomfield Road.
When Julia and Bobby had moved into Blomfield Road, Mimi’s concerns began, as John’s mother was now living less than two miles walking distance from Mendips and Mimi wasn’t sure how long she could conceal this fact from the nine-year-old John. In the summer of 1949 just after Julia had moved to Blomfield, the Stanley sisters including Mimi all met at Anne Georgina “Nanny” Cadwallader’s home “Ardmore” in Rock Ferry once owned by Elizabeth Jane “Mater” and her husband Stanley Parkes. Mimi would have had no control over the quality time John spent with his mother that day, and Julia who was pregnant with Bobby’s second child, had plenty of love to give to her first born. Mimi would most certainly have been outnumbered by her other siblings, however once back at Mendips with her nephew she could actively discourage contact with Julia and refuse John to mention her name.
Mimi didn’t approve of her sister’s relationship with Bobby Dykins, living in sin with their two illegitimate children as she called Julia and Jackie. Jacqueline “Jackie “Geraldine Dykins was born at Sefton General Hospital on the 26th of October 1949, two months premature. Julia was happy with her family and all she wanted was John to join them at 1 Blomfield Road and she always kept a bedroom spare for him, and John was continued to be loved by his mother, but Mimi was adamant, no contact or even visits to Mendips.
Mimi’s famous quote was that 1 Blomfield Road was “The House of Sin” and Mendips Menlove Avenue was “The House of Correction”, however these quotes came to bite into Mimi Smith’s reputation in decades to come.
However, Julia was not going to give upon her son, she would see him, with or without her sister Mimi’s permission and fortunately John felt the same way and he would see his mother. About eight months after the party at Ardmore and in the Easter holidays of April 1950, Mimi’s nephew Stanley Parkes came to visit Liverpool from his home in Edinburgh, catching the bus from Edinburgh to the Liverpool Ribble bus station. Stanley was the son of Charles Molyneaux and Elizabeth Jane “Mater” Parkes nee Stanley and he and John were very close. When Stanley came for a visit, his mother had given him Julia’s address and even though Mimi forbid John to go to Blomfield Road with Stanley, his cousin disobeyed her orders and on false pretences he got John to see his mother and Mimi had lost the battle. Stanley had told John “Don’t tell Mimi”and John was to repeat this refrain until he died.
John continued over the next four years visiting his family at Blomfield and when he started school at Quarry Bank it was much easier to visit Springwood. By 1954 Mimi knew where John was going, and she had to face facts her beloved John was spending as much time with his mother as he could, and he became less circumspect with Mimi concerning where he was spending his time. So, Mimi and Julia came to an agreement and Julia was allowed to spend time with John and herself at Mendips however Mimi was still not happy at John wanting to stay at Blomfield and in the summer of 1955 when John was fourteen Mimi sent him to stay with his aunty Nanny and his cousin Michael, just to keep John away from his mother. Mimi just couldn’t let go.
Then on the 5th of June 1955 tragedy was to strike the family when Mimi’s husband George passed away at the young age of fifty-two. On the Sunday afternoon of the 4th of June Mimi and her lodger Michael John Fishwick heard a crash on the stairs and on entering the hallway found George collapsed. Michael Fishwick called an ambulance and George was taken to the Smithdown (Sefton) General Hospital where he died on Sunday the 5th of June 1955 and cause of death, established during a post-mortem, was a burst abdomen and “cirrhosis of liver (non-alcoholic)” and contradicts many stories that George was a hopeless alcoholic. John wasn’t informed of his uncle’s death so when he returned from Durness Scotland it was to a home without his uncle George. George Toogood Smith was buried on the 7th of June 1955 at St Peter’s Churchyard Woolton where two years later John Lennon would meet Paul McCartney at the church fete on the 6th of July 1957.
On the day of the funeral John presented his aunt Mimi with a poem and Mimi had always encouraged the young Lennon to read and write poetry, and this poem touched her heart. John despaired at Mimi’s siblings including his own mother, for their lack of feelings towards Mimi after the death of her husband George. The poem was written when John was nearly fifteen with a little help from the iconic American star Frank Sinatra. When i say help, John used the lyrics from the third line of Frank Sinatra’s song “Young at Heart”, and this was the poem.
"The worry and strife, that's been wont to her life.
Has driven her family to shame.
If they should survive, to one hundred and five.
They could never repay her again.
Each one in their turn, will finally learn.
That she is the best of the five
Each one of them slept, not one of them wept.
At the struggle of her mate to survive.
7/6/55. J. W. Lennon"
So, after Georges death it was just Mimi, John and her favourite lodger Michael J Fishwick and the lodgers were her only source of income, her husband had left the sum of £2407.11s.9d (Probate administration took place on the 22nd of June 1955).
Sometime during the Autumn of 1956 Mimi Smith began living a secret life at Mendips, which she kept from her siblings and John, and it was only discovered many decades later after the sisters and John himself had passed away, by John’s half-sister Julia Baird nee Dykins.
Even though Mimi had kept the secret as she thought, there was one sister Anne Georgina “Nanny” that had an inkling something was going on in Mimi’s life, but she thought it was their cousin George Matthews who was living in New Zealand. Nanny was clear in her discussions with Julia Baird that she thought Mimi was off to New Zealand and she was on the right track with the place but not with the man.
Michael J Fishwick started lodging with Mimi and George in 1951 when John was only eleven years old and when Michael came to lodge with the Smiths, he was nineteen and about to study biochemistry at Liverpool university.
It was in about the Autumn of 1956 a year following her husband’s death, Mimi began her secret affair, and it appears from reading Julia Baird’s book “Imagine This” that it was only her sibling “Nanny” that had any inclination of an affair, and she was positive that it was her cousin George.
By the Autumn of 1956 John was frequently staying over at Blomfield Road with his Mum and suddenly Mimi was happy to let him visit, presumably so she could spend quality time with Michael J Fishwick whom she had already developed a close friendship with, before it turned into a love affair. Mimi had told Michael she was only forty-six years old when in fact by 1956 she was fifty and he was twenty-four, but the age gap didn’t deter either of them especially Mimi.
Not long after the affair began Mimi took John to Scotland just after Christmas to celebrate the New Year with her sister Mater and by now John had celebrated his sixteenth birthday. Michael Fishwick returned to Mendips shortly after Christmas to study but contracted Asian Flu. He telephoned Mimi in Scotland, and she left John with his aunt while she returned to Mendips to care for Michael, well so they could have the house to themselves. Mimi would have found it difficult to keep her love affair from prying eyes and especially from young John. Memories of her fiancé back in the late 1920’s at the Liverpool Convalescent Hospital would have come flooding back when Michael contracted Asian Flu, she surely wasn’t going to lose him, the thought for Mimi would have been unbearable.
Decades later and after Mimi’s death, Julia Baird nee Dykins finally met up with Michael J Fishwick and discovered that he was in fact Mimi’s secret love affair and it was hard for Julia to accept, but in fact she felt sorry for her aunt. The truth of Mimi and Michael’s affair must have hurt the family as Mimi chose to judge her sister Julia’s lifestyle at Blomfield calling her home the despised House of Sin while hers was the House of Correction. Beatles historians speculate as that is what we do, and in this scenario, you can only feel that decades later the family must have been thinking of the greatest possible hypocrisy. Mimi was having a secret affair with a man only nine years older than John living under the same roof at Mendips so was this really the House of Correction.
Nanny, Mimi’s younger sister thought it was someone in New Zealand, she was correct with the place but not with the man. Michael J Fishwick was offered a three-year research post in 1957 in New Zealand, so Nanny was almost right.
Mimi was to jump at the chance to move to New Zealand and bribed Michael with the fact that if they embarked on a new life together then she would give him her cottage at 120a Allerton Road. Mimi knew John would be happy to go and live with his mother at Blomfield and Mimi was ready to let him go. What happened next possibly left Mimi desperate once more, life for her was going to change and challenges and more adventures were certainly heading her way. Michael Fishwick’s funding for his postgraduate research was refused, meaning he was no longer exempt from National Service, and a few months later he left Mendips to join up. Mimi and Michael remained good friends but left to further his career and find himself a wife that he could have children with, leaving behind presumably a distraught Mimi for the third time, with only her beloved John to care for, even though he was steering towards becoming a pop star, well that was his idea, but Mimi was totally against such a career.
Michael John Fishwick was born on the 3rd of March 1932 to Herbert and Lucy Jane Fishwick nee Ribbons, and their home was 5 Armley Grange View, Leeds where Michaels parents lived all their life. Michaels father Herbert was born on the 26th of March 1893 to John and Alice Fishwick nee Turner at Leigh in Lancashire. Herbert married Lucy Jane Ribbons (born the 5th of May 1892) on the 20th of August 1927 at St Johns Church Roundhay five miles south of Leeds city centre. At the beginning of WW ll in September 1939 Michaels father remained at 5 Armley Grange View while his wife Lucy and young Michael moved to 367 Lytham Road Blackpool where they presumably evacuated, away from the city centre. Michaels father Herbert was a second accountant for a retail clothing company. When his son Michael wanted to study Biochemistry at Liverpool his father Herbert accompanied him to view and approve his lodgings at 251 Menlove Avenue. Herbert Fishwick died on the 16th of September 1974 and his wife Lucy died on the 28th of March 1988 and both Michael’s parents were wealthy people.
Whilst researching the Fishwick family I made personal contact with one of Michael’s nephews by marriage, whom for their privacy will remain anonymous.
After Michael left Mendips, he moved to Aberdeen to work in the marine laboratory, and it was here that he met his future wife also working in the same place. Her name was Alice Barbara Peck nee McLauchlin born on the 29th of June 1923 to Christopher and Priscilla Thompson McLauchlin nee Dick, Alice had been married previously to Eric Blythe Peck and they were married at Gordon House, Inverurie Aberdeen on the 23rd of June 1949 and had one daughter. in October 1962 Alice married Michael J Fishwick in Cambridge and in 1966 they were living at 19 Willow Crescent Cambridge and now had two children of their own, a daughter and a son. Michael now could add doctor to his name, and he was known as Dr Michael John Fishwick and by the 1970’s they were residing in Norwich Norfolk where he settled down to a very different life than if he had stayed with Mimi. He was now blessed with good job prospects, a wife and three lovely children but Michael had a dark secret that he would share one day. Michael’s wife Alice died on the 8th of January 2004 at the age of eighty and Michael himself passed away on the 29th of September 2015 eleven years later both passing away at their home in Norwich.
The Marine Laboratory has had a presence in the southeast of Aberdeen since 1898 and has a strong focus on fisheries and shellfisheries.
A fascinating story about a man whose life crossed paths with the young John Lennon during the 1950’s at Mendips although if John had known the truth about his aunt Mimi and her lodger Michael Fishwick, I am not sure how he would have felt. Michael would certainly have witnessed many dramas between Mimi and her sister Julia over the years he resided at Mendips. Michael built a close relationship with Mimi, but their life together wasn’t meant to be, and they went their separate ways.
Michael’s relative informed me that Michael had recorded a tape for the National Trust when he returned to Mendips decades later and when he met up with Julia Baird to reveal his secret life with Mimi, he showed her a pair of cufflinks which Mimi had given him and ones that originally had been a gift to her fiancé, the doctor at the Liverpool Convalescent Hospital.
Michael stayed at Mendips until the December of 1958 and had been around to witness the tragic death of Johns mother Julia, shortly after she had left Mendips to get the bus home to Springwood. *
So, by the Christmas of 1958 life for Mimi was very different as in that year she had lost her sibling Julia and her lover Michael Fishwick however her beloved John was still at her side but not for long and Mimi was about to face more adventures and challenges, life taking a very different turn for Mimi Smith.
My next and final blog on the first born of the Stanley girls will cover my research on Mimi’s final years at Mendips and then her move to Sandbanks in Dorset.
· Julia’s death to be covered in a future blog on the fourth of the Stanley girls.
Before I leave the blog, I just wanted to share that i had the privilege of staying at 1 Blomfield Road on the 27th of May 2022, then owned by Jackie Holmes and would like to thank her for the opportunity of having the amazing experience of staying within the walls of Mimi’s “House of Sin”. Personally, I feel it was the house where John found happiness with his mother for a short period in their lives.